'Breakthrough' to Reality of Medical Headlines

What's in a headline?

The point of a headline - of course - is to grab your attention so you'll want to buy the newspaper or magazine or spend more time on the Website. While the above headline is fictional, it looks like headlines we've all seen.

What do you think when you see such sensational headlines? Here's some advice:

If the headline looks too good to be true, chances are it is.

Have some healthy skepticism when certain words appear in the headline. Words such as "breakthrough," "promising," and "victim," all create an emotional response.

Look to see if the information comes from a medical journal or a press release. Certain medical journals such as The New England Journal of Medicine, Lancet, Science, JAMA, and Annals of Internal Medicine all have high standards for publication. So do many other specialty journals. But there are also magazines that publish opinion rather than science.

Check out Health News Review on the Web for grades on health news reporting. Experienced health news reporters developed this Website.

Medical science advances slowly, with studies being repeated by others to ensure reliable results. That means that there are very few “breakthroughs.” Thorough medical researchers don't want to accept as true the results from a single study. They want to see it repeated with the same outcomes. Most advances come by adding to past improvements. This means that medical achievements come in increments and not sudden "breakthroughs."

The problem, of course, with medical sensationalism is that it may give people false hope or - on the other hand - undue fears. This happened recently when Time magazine ran an article titled “How Safe Are Vaccines?” complete with a picture of a 6-week-old infant who was “bravely facing his five immunizations.” The caption serves as another example of using emotionally-charged words to set a tone rather than provide facts.

The actual article in Time was a well-balanced review of the science, opinion, and government actions concerning evaluation of new vaccines for children. But the headline caused enough concern that the American Academy of Pediatrics had to send parent information to the nation's pediatricians. After the Time article and other sensational television pieces, immunization rates fell. The following year saw the country's first outbreaks of measles in years.

Clearly, there can be significant consequences to sensational reporting or medical stories.

About the author

Dr. Tom James

Dr. James is the Healthcare Advisor for Humana's Strategic Advisory Group. Dr. James is board-certified in Internal Medicine and in Pediatrics. He received his undergraduate degree from Duke University and his medical degree from the University of Kentucky.

Links to various other Websites from this site are provided for your convenience only and do not constitute or imply endorsement by Humana of these sites, any products or services described on these sites, or of any other material contained therein. Humana disclaims responsibility for their content and accuracy.

Medical Plans

Humana group medical plans are offered by Humana Medical Plan, Inc., Humana Employers Health Plan of Georgia, Inc., Humana Health Plan, Inc., Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana, Inc., Humana Health Plan of Ohio, Inc., Humana Health Plans of Puerto Rico, Inc. License # 00235-0008, Humana Wisconsin Health Organization Insurance Corporation, or Humana Health Plan of Texas, Inc., or insured by Humana Health Insurance Company of Florida, Inc., Humana Health Plan, Inc., Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana, Inc., Humana Insurance Company, Humana Insurance Company of Kentucky, Humana Insurance of Puerto Rico, Inc. License # 00187-0009, or administered by Humana Insurance Company or Humana Health Plan, Inc. For Arizona residents, plans are offered by Humana Health Plan, Inc. or insured by Humana Insurance Company. Administered by Humana Insurance Company.

Go365^® is not an insurance product. Not available with all Humana health plans.

Individual Dental and Vision Plans

Humana Individual dental and vision plans are insured or offered by Humana Insurance Company, HumanaDental Insurance Company, Humana Insurance Company of New York, The Dental Concern, Inc., CompBenefits Insurance Company, CompBenefits Company, CompBenefits Dental, Inc., Humana Employers Health Plan of Georgia, Inc. or Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana, Inc. Discount plans offered by HumanaDental Insurance Company or Humana Insurance Company. For Arizona residents: Insured by Humana Insurance Company. For Texas residents: Insured or offered by Humana Insurance Company, HumanaDental Insurance Company or DentiCare, Inc (d/b/a Compbenefits).

In states, and for products where applicable, the premium may include a $1 administrative fee. If you have purchased an association plan, an association fee may also apply. Some plans may also charge a one-time, non-refundable enrollment fee. (This fee is non-refundable as allowed by state).

A minimum one-year, initial contract period may be required for some dental and vision plans, excluding Dental Savings Plus

Group Dental and Vision Plans (Insurance through your employer)

Humana group dental plans are offered by Humana Insurance Company, HumanaDental Insurance Company, Humana Insurance Company of New York, The Dental Concern, Inc., Humana Medical Plan of Utah, Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana, CompBenefits Company, CompBenefits Insurance Company, CompBenefits Dental, Inc., Humana Employers Health Plan of Georgia, Inc., or DentiCare, Inc. (DBA CompBenefits).

Humana group vision plans are offered by Humana Insurance Company, HumanaDental Insurance Company, Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana, Humana Insurance Company of Kentucky, Humana Insurance Company of New York, CompBenefits Insurance Company, CompBenefits Company, or The Dental Concern, Inc.

Life Insurance Plans

Humana group life plans are offered by Humana Insurance Company or Humana Insurance Company of Kentucky.

Limitations and exclusions

This communication provides a general description of certain identified insurance or non-insurance benefits provided under one or more of our health benefit plans. Our health benefit plans have exclusions and limitations and terms under which the coverage may be continued in force or discontinued. For costs and complete details of the coverage, refer to the plan document or call or write Humana, or your Humana insurance agent or broker. In the event of any disagreement between this communication and the plan document, the plan document will control.

Individual applications are subject to eligibility requirements.

Before applying for group coverage, please refer to the pre-enrollment disclosures for a description of plan provisions which may exclude, limit, reduce, modify or terminate your coverage. View plan provisions or check with your sales representative.

For group plans, please refer to your Benefit Plan Document (Certificate of Coverage/Insurance or Summary Plan Description/Administrative Services Only) for more information on the company providing your benefits.

Statements in languages other than English contained in the advertisement do not necessarily reflect the exact contents of the policy written in English, because of possible linguistic differences. In the event of a dispute, the policy as written in English is considered the controlling authority.

'Breakthrough' to Reality of Medical Headlines

What's in a headline?

What it means to you

About the author

Stay motivated to stay active

Read between the lines

Celebrate 100 birthdays – or more!